CARD Act Loophole Number 73 – Student Loans are Income, Apparently

Student-loans-are-income The CARD Act requires that lenders now take steps to ensure that their applicants have some sort of ability to pay their debt obligations. The fact that it took a Federal law to accomplish this is a head-scratcher for sure. The question is, how are lenders doing this and how are they navigating around and through the requirement?

First off, your credit reports don’t contain your salary, so that’s a dead end. Second, your credit risk scores are not designed to predict capacity to pay, but are rather designed to predict the likelihood of you paying so that’s a dead end too. And lastly, trusting what you put on your credit application as “income” has proven to be unreliable, so that’s not really an option either.

This is certainly a capacity conundrum. And, since the world of credit is not without humor, I gladly bring you CARD Act loophole number 73: Student loans and the “no cards for those under 21” rule. A student loan is a real loan with strange terms. It’s issued by a bank and is sometimes federally guaranteed. The monies are generally disbursed quarterly or each semester to coincide with the school’s preferred method of slicing up the school year. The loans are meant to go toward funding tuition and college related costs.

What allows student loans to become a loophole to the CARD Act capacity to pay provision is the fact that most student loans are paid to the student rather than to the school directly. Then the student uses it to pay for tuition and books and other school expenses, or at least that’s the plan. I know people who used their student loans for expenses that would never be confused with scholastic expenses.

And if what we’re hearing is true, credit card issuers are considering student loans to be income rather than a liability. It seems to make sense to do so considering there is no immediate obligation to pay back a student loan, and by the time the loan enters the payback period the student will likely be employed. But still, if 100% of the loan is meant to be paid to the school, how can it be income?


John Ulzheimer – Credit scoring and credit reporting expert and author, John is the President of Consumer Education for Credit.com. Formerly with Equifax and Fair Isaac, John shares his unique insight of the inner workings of credit scoring models and the credit reporting industry on CreditBloggers.com.

CARD Act Loophole Number 73 – Student Loans are Income, Apparently

Student-loans-are-income The CARD Act requires that lenders now take steps to ensure that their applicants have some sort of ability to pay their debt obligations. The fact that it took a Federal law to accomplish this is a head-scratcher for sure. The question is, how are lenders doing this and how are they navigating around and through the requirement?

First off, your credit reports don’t contain your salary, so that’s a dead end. Second, your credit risk scores are not designed to predict capacity to pay, but are rather designed to predict the likelihood of you paying so that’s a dead end too. And lastly, trusting what you put on your credit application as “income” has proven to be unreliable, so that’s not really an option either.

This is certainly a capacity conundrum. And, since the world of credit is not without humor, I gladly bring you CARD Act loophole number 73: Student loans and the “no cards for those under 21” rule. A student loan is a real loan with strange terms. It’s issued by a bank and is sometimes federally guaranteed. The monies are generally disbursed quarterly or each semester to coincide with the school’s preferred method of slicing up the school year. The loans are meant to go toward funding tuition and college related costs.

What allows student loans to become a loophole to the CARD Act capacity to pay provision is the fact that most student loans are paid to the student rather than to the school directly. Then the student uses it to pay for tuition and books and other school expenses, or at least that’s the plan. I know people who used their student loans for expenses that would never be confused with scholastic expenses.

And if what we’re hearing is true, credit card issuers are considering student loans to be income rather than a liability. It seems to make sense to do so considering there is no immediate obligation to pay back a student loan, and by the time the loan enters the payback period the student will likely be employed. But still, if 100% of the loan is meant to be paid to the school, how can it be income?


John Ulzheimer – Credit scoring and credit reporting expert and author, John is the President of Consumer Education for Credit.com. Formerly with Equifax and Fair Isaac, John shares his unique insight of the inner workings of credit scoring models and the credit reporting industry on CreditBloggers.com.

Business Credit Cards: Are They Worth It?

Watch your mailbox. You could be getting applications for small business credit cards – even if you aren’t a business owner. A recent Wall Street Journal article points out that card issuers appear to be increasing their marketing of business cards – even to consumers who work for someone else. Sometimes camouflaged in vague terms like “professional” cards, these cards come with a serious disadvantage for the cardholder:

Business credit cards are not covered by the Credit CARD Act.

 

That means issuers can raise rates with little advance notice (and apply them retroactively), charge higher penalty fees, play with floating due dates, and do all those fun things they used to do with consumer credit cards before those tactics were outlawed. 

So why on earth would anyone want a small business credit card? Believe it or not, there are a few good reasons:

Business Card Pros:

Protect your personal credit scores. With the notable exception of Capital One, which has chosen to report business card activity on personal credit reports, most business credit cards aren't reported on personal credit reports unless you default. That means if your business can't afford to pay the bill in full each month, the fact that you are carrying a balance won't weigh down your personal credit scores. (Speaking of credit scores, you should expect to see an inquiry on at least one of your personal credit reports, since most of these cards require a personal credit check.)

Separate your business and personal finances: If you actually do own a business, keeping your business and personal purchases separate can be crucial for tax purposes. Having a dedicated business card makes this easier, though another alternative would be to use a personal card strictly for business purchases. Again, though, the activity on a personal card affects your personal credit scores, for better or for worse. 

Rich rewards:  You may find richer rewards on some small business credit cards. American Express, for example, is well known for both catering to small businesses, as well as offering solid rewards. The CitiBusiness AAdvantage Visa card gives 30,000 AAdvantage bonus miles if you make $750 in purchases the first four months. That's not hard to do if you are funding a new business.

Business Card Cons

Open yourself to the old tricks and traps. You can read our Consumer Guide to the Credit CARD Act here if you want more details about the practices that Congress banned on consumer cards. But I'll say it again: The CARD Act does not apply to business accounts. And that includes cards marketed to non-business owners as “professional” cards – at least for the time being. (I can see the new Consumer Financial Protection Bureau having fun with this one.)

Note: Bank of America has stated they will extend many of the Credit CARD Act provisions to their business cards. A Capital One spokesperson is quoted in the WSJ article as saying that Capital One has applied many CARD Act protections to its business cards, but when I look at their web site, their card offers still list penalty fees that are now illegal on consumer cards.

We've said it before and we'll say it again. Just because the CARD Act protections are in place doesn't mean we can rest easy. There are still plenty of traps to watch out for.

 

 

Gerri Detweiler – Personal finance author and Credit Advisor for Credit.com, Gerri contributes budgeting, debt recovery and savings information online. She is also the co-author of a new ebook, Business Credit Success: Get on the Financing Fast Track.

 

New Credit Card Laws: Final Phase Begins

The third and final phase of the Credit Card Act of 2009 went into effect yesterday, on Aug. 22. And while most of the provisions went into effect in February of this year, the remaining provisions include some pretty significant changes that you should know about.

To help explain what these final changes mean for you, Adam Levin, chairman and founder of Credit.com, was invited to appear yesterday on ABC's Good Morning America. Watch the clip to hear more about the final changes pertaining to credit card fees, the new 6-month interest rate review mandate and new gift card rules that went into effect yesterday:


Fee Changes:

  • Credit card issuers cannot charge you an inactivity fee for not using your card, including fees for not charging a certain amount each month.

  • Credit card issuers cannot charge you a late fee greater than your minimum payment.

Interest Rate Reviews:

  • If your rate was increased because of late payments, you must be given the opportunity to earn back your previous rate. By paying your account on time for six consecutive months, your credit card issuer must lower your interest rate back to the rate it was before the increase.
  • If your rate was increased after January 1, 2009 for any reason, beginning in February 2011, your card issuer must review your account every six months to determine whether the reasons behind the rate increase still apply. If not, they must reduce the rate, though there is no specific amount by which it must be lowered.

Gift Card Changes:

  • Gift cards, prepaid cards and gift certificates cannot expire within five years of activation, unless the terms and expiration are clearly disclosed before it’s purchased. If you load additional funds onto a card, the five year expiration period is extended by five years.

Thanks to the CARD Act, consumers are no longer solely at the mercy of their credit card issuer's whims. If you'd like more information on the CARD Act and want to know what changes you'll see with each provision, be sure to check out Credit.com's Consumer Guide: How the Credit CARD Act of 2009 Affects You.


The Credit CARD Act: Payment Allocations & Billing Cycles

Card-act-graphic We're wrapping up our week long series on the Credit CARD Act.  For those of you just joining us, we've been gearing up for the final changes that are scheduled to go into effect on Aug. 22.

So far we've covered all of the major provisions that have gone into effect to date, including what you need to know about interest rates and account changes, fee restrictions, student protections, and enhanced consumer disclosures.


The final section of the Act relates to how your payments are allocated, statement mailing requirements, and billing cycle changes.  Here's what you need to know:

  • Credit card issuers are required to mail your statement at least 21 days before your payment is due and your monthly due date must be the same date each month.

  • Double-cycle billing, or the practice of calculating interest charges on both the current balance and the previous month's balance, is prohibited.

  • Any payment over the minimum balance due must automatically be applied to the highest interest balance first.

What you need to know: Before a credit card issuer can open a new account, they must first take into account your ability to repay. A card issuer cannot open a new credit card account, or increase an existing credit limit, unless they first consider your ability to make the required payments under the terms on the account.


There's no question that the CARD Act is a great step forward for consumer protection, but we have one final phase left to go. The remaining provisions will go into effect on August 22, 2010, and include the final rules that limit fees on gift cards and also gives consumers the right to earn back their previous interest rate if they are able to make continuous on time payments for 6 months.  Join us on Monday, where we'll review the final provisions and wrap up the final chapter in this series.

Powered by Yahoo! Answers